Why Interviewers Ask This Question
- •To assess your leadership style and potential
- •To understand how you influence others without direct authority
- •To evaluate your decision-making in high-stakes situations
- •To see if you can drive results through others
- •To determine readiness for senior or management roles
How to Structure Your Answer: STAR Method
The gold standard for behavioral interview questions.
- 1
Situation - Set the context (2-3 sentences)
- 2
Task - Explain the challenge or goal you faced
- 3
Action - Describe specific steps YOU took (focus on "I", not "we")
- 4
Result - Share measurable outcomes and what you learned
Generic vs. Personalized Answer
Generic Answer
What most candidates say
"At my previous company, we had a project that was falling behind schedule. I stepped up to lead the team and we worked really hard to get things back on track. I delegated tasks, motivated the team, and we successfully delivered the project on time. Everyone was happy with the result and it showed my leadership skills."
Why this falls short:
- •No specific context or stakes (what project? why behind?)
- •Vague actions ("worked really hard", "motivated the team")
- •No evidence of actual leadership decisions or trade-offs
- •No metrics or measurable outcomes
- •Uses "we" instead of "I" — unclear what YOU specifically did
- •No learning or reflection
Personalized Answer
Based on your specific experiences
Situation: Last year, I was an IC engineer when our engineering manager unexpectedly left during our biggest product launch — a complete platform redesign affecting 500K users. We were 6 weeks from deadline with no technical leader and a demoralized team of 7 engineers. Task: While the company searched for a replacement manager, someone needed to step up immediately. I volunteered to lead the team temporarily, despite never having managed before. My goal was to ship on time without burning out the team or sacrificing quality. Action: First, I did 1-on-1s with each engineer to understand their concerns. I discovered that 3 people were ready to quit because the previous manager had been toxic. I couldn't fix that, but I could set a different tone. I made three key decisions: (1) I reorganized our sprint from 40 tickets into 12 "must-haves" and 28 "nice-to-haves," giving the team a realistic goal. (2) I instituted "no-meeting Thursdays" so engineers had deep focus time. (3) I created a public "blockers" doc that I updated daily, escalating anything stuck for >24 hours to the VP. Hardest decision: When QA found a critical bug 2 days before launch, I made the call to delay by one week rather than ship broken. I personally called our top 50 customers to explain and offer early access to beta testing as compensation. Result: We launched 1 week late, but with zero critical bugs. Customer satisfaction scores were 4.8/5 (vs. 3.9/5 for previous launch). Three engineers who were planning to leave stayed on. I learned that leadership isn't about having all the answers — it's about creating clarity, removing obstacles, and making tough calls with incomplete information. The VP eventually asked me to stay on as Engineering Manager. I accepted and have been leading that team for 8 months now.
Why this works:
- •Vivid situation with high stakes (manager left, major launch, demoralized team)
- •Clear ownership of volunteering despite no experience
- •Specific leadership actions with reasoning (1-on-1s, sprint reorganization, no-meeting Thursdays)
- •Demonstrates empathy (understanding why people wanted to quit)
- •Shows tough decision-making (delaying launch, calling customers personally)
- •Quantifies results (4.8/5 satisfaction, retention)
- •Reflects on leadership lesson learned
- •Proves lasting impact (became permanent manager)
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- •Choosing an example where you had formal authority (e.g., already a manager)
- •Taking credit for team success without explaining YOUR specific contributions
- •Only describing what went well, not challenges or trade-offs
- •Rambling through unnecessary details instead of being concise
- •Not explaining WHY you made certain decisions
- •Focusing on activity rather than impact
- •Forgetting to mention what you learned
Expert Tips
- •Leadership without title is more impressive than leadership with title
- •Include a specific difficult decision you made — that's what separates leaders
- •Quantify the impact on people (retention, morale) and business (metrics)
- •Show vulnerability — what was hard? what would you do differently?
- •Keep Situation and Task brief (30 seconds), spend time on Action (60 seconds) and Result (30 seconds)
- •Use present-tense when describing your thought process for vivid storytelling
- •Have 2-3 leadership stories ready covering different contexts
The Psychology Behind Interview Success
Daniel Kahneman
Thinking, Fast and Slow (2011)
Your opening answer sets the tone. Practice until your first 30 seconds are polished and confident—it creates a halo effect for everything that follows.
Amy Cuddy
Presence (2015)
Lead with warmth, not just credentials. Smile genuinely, show enthusiasm, acknowledge others' contributions before showcasing your own.
Robert Cialdini
Influence (1984)
Give value in the interview—share insights, offer ideas, show genuine interest in their challenges. Don't just take (ask for job) without giving (demonstrating value).
Elizabeth Loftus
Eyewitness Testimony Research (1970s-present)
Include specific details in your stories (dates, numbers, names). Vague answers feel fabricated; vivid details feel authentic.
From Our Blog
Why IIM Candidates Who Know Everything Still Blank Mid-Answer
You've prepared for months. You know all the current affairs. So why do you freeze when the IIM panel asks a question you definitely know? Here's the working memory problem that destroys candidates.
Ready to Practice?
Put these tips into action with AI-powered mock interviews tailored to your background
Start A Rehearsal — Free