Asked by: IIM Ahmedabad, IIM Calcutta
WAT Topic: "Is reservation policy still relevant in modern India?" - social category, hard difficulty. Consider 2 perspectives for a balanced essay.
Reference recent data on SC/ST representation. State: still needed, but needs reform.
Para 1: Evidence that discrimination persists
Para 2: Valid critiques of current implementation
Para 3: Proposed reforms (economic criteria, creamy layer expansion)
Don't abolish, but evolve the policy with economic criteria and sunset clauses.
Taking an extreme anti-reservation stance
Not knowing the constitutional basis (Articles 15, 16)
Ignoring data on continued discrimination
This is a sensitive topic. Lead with empathy and data, not ideology. Know the 50% cap from Indira Sawhney case.
Rhetoric (4th Century BC)
Insight: Persuasion requires ethos (credibility), pathos (emotion), and logos (logic) working together.
How to apply: Structure your WAT with logical arguments (logos), establish credibility through data/examples (ethos), and connect to human impact (pathos). IIM evaluators look for all three.
Made to Stick (2007)
Insight: Ideas that stick are Simple, Unexpected, Concrete, Credible, Emotional, and tell Stories (SUCCESs).
How to apply: Open with an unexpected fact or angle. Use concrete examples, not abstractions. Ground arguments in credible data. Make it memorable.
The Sense of Style (2014)
Insight: Good writing is about showing the reader something in the world, not performing your knowledge.
How to apply: Don't write to impress—write to illuminate. Avoid jargon and pompous language. Show you understand the issue, don't just list points.
Politics and the English Language (1946)
Insight: Clear thinking leads to clear writing. Never use a long word where a short one will do.
How to apply: Prefer active voice. Cut unnecessary words. If you can cut a word, cut it. Clarity beats complexity in 200-word essays.
Values original thinking and nuanced positions over conventional wisdom.
Tip: IIMA loves contrarian but well-reasoned takes. Don't be afraid to challenge the premise of the topic itself.
Practical, business-oriented evaluation. Values structured thinking.
Tip: IIMB appreciates when you connect topics to business/management implications. Always include "so what" for managers.
Rigorous analytical approach. Values data and economic reasoning.
Tip: IIMC loves numbers. Include at least one relevant statistic. Show you understand economic trade-offs.
Balanced evaluation of content and expression.
Tip: IIML values clear structure. Use explicit transitions and signposting.
Ethics-focused, values human-centric perspectives.
Tip: XLRI's Jesuit heritage means they value ethical dimensions. Always consider the human/social impact angle.
There's no "right" stance. What matters is taking a clear position and defending it well. This is a sensitive topic. Lead with empathy and data, not ideology. Know the 50% cap from Indira Sawhney case.
This topic has been asked by: IIM Ahmedabad, IIM Calcutta.
Reference recent data on SC/ST representation. State: still needed, but needs reform. Your body should cover: Para 1: Evidence that discrimination persists; Para 2: Valid critiques of current implementation; Para 3: Proposed reforms (economic criteria, creamy layer expansion).
Our AI simulates the follow-up questions panels ask after reading your essay — testing if you truly understand what you wrote.
Experience a Mock Interview